Monday, November 30, 2009
is Holden holding back?
Last week Mr. Kunkle was talking to Hannah and I and he brought up the possibility of Holden being homosexual. At first I thought no way, but then I began to think about all the scenes that Holden is interacting with girls. He is often trying to find a girl to spend time with, but he never seems to be comfortable around any of the girls. Another big sign in the book was that Holden, although he has many opportunities, never actually does anything with any of the girls. He always chickens out at the last minute, or does something super awkward. Like when he's on a date with Sally, and Holden tells her he wants to run away and marry her. After processing all these events, and the book as a whole, I've come to the conclusion that it's very possible Salinger wanted to make the reader think Holden could have been homosexual. Ultimately, I think he wrote the book to let the reader decide for themselves, and I've decided that while all these events/thoughts are evidence to support that he is, I don't believe he is. I think Holden just has so much going on with himself, and isn't feeling confident enough with himself to have any type of relationship. However, that's just the conclusion I've drawn after reading Catcher in the Rye.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Yeah. When Mr. Kunkle mentioned that I really didn't go for it. I think that his relationship with Sally (holding her hand, getting jealous/mad with Stradlater giving her 'the time') proves that he is hetero. It was an interesting suggestion, but I don't think there was any concrete proof of Holden being gay.
ReplyDelete